Switch Clip

Blog · Production notes

How to Get Useful Feedback on Shorts: Ask for Time and Reason

When the feedback is 'it feels off,' ask back 'Around which second?' and 'Because of what?' With a time and a reason attached, what needs fixing narrows to a single spot. You no longer have to redo the whole video.

Why vague feedback is hard to use

That 'off' feeling can come from the captions, the sound or the timing of a cut. If you do not know where, you end up touching everything, and even the good parts change. So ask about the location before you fix anything.

Questions to ask back

  • Around which second did you feel that?
  • Was it the picture, the sound or the captions that bothered you?
  • Do you have a picture of how you'd like it to be?
  • On the other hand, which parts would you like kept as they are?

How to turn feedback into edits

  1. 1

    Put it in a table

    Write the time, the what and the why, one row each.

  2. 2

    Easy ones first

    Handle what you can fix right away, like caption typos.

  3. 3

    One thing at a time

    Make big changes one by one and show it again.

  4. 4

    Get it confirmed

    Give the timestamp of the fixed part and ask them to watch just that.

Use the same method when you check alone

If there is no one to give feedback, watch it once with the sound off and once with the picture covered. Write down the times of the moments that catch, and you have the same table. Find the captions that catch in the Switch Clip preview and fix them before exporting.

Pick a video, get up to 6 Shorts

Switch Clip gathers videos you are allowed to reuse and public-domain classics. Pick one and you get Shorts with captions, a title, commentary and the credit line. Your first one is free, no sign-up.

Make a Short for free

Frequently asked questions

What if the feedback is just 'I don't like it'?

Ask at around which second they first wanted to swipe away. That one spot is your starting point for fixing it.

Do I have to act on all the feedback?

Start with the points that come with a clear reason. When opinions differ, choose the side that fits the video's goal.

What's the most common reason a Short feels off?

A cut in the middle of a sentence, captions that do not match the picture, and sound that suddenly gets loud are common. Check those three first.

Keep reading